Hotels have an interesting habit of resenting the OTAs despite relying heavily on the demand they generate.
The commissions are too high. They bid on our brand terms. They steal our bookings. They own the customer.
And yet we own the hotel, the entire guest experience, and every customer touchpoint from check-in to checkout.
Then the guest goes home and books their next stay through an OTA.
Why?
Because we let them.
If the OTA already has all the guest’s contact information, offers the better rate, an easier booking experience, stronger loyalty benefits, and better visibility, what do we expect the guest to do?
Guests are going to choose the path that offers the most value with the least friction.
Too many hotels still fail that test.
The key to winning more direct bookings is understanding what we as hoteliers are doing wrong, and what the OTAs are doing right.
For everything hotels dislike about OTAs, there’s a reason we keep doing business with them: they work.
OTAs can be incredibly valuable partners because they are essentially matchmakers. They spend enormous amounts of money finding travelers, building audiences, creating demand, and helping consumers sort through hundreds of options.
A traveler picks a destination and needs a hotel.
The OTA introduces them to you.
This is the true value of the relationship. They find the customer, create the introduction, and deliver the guest to you.
That first booking can be a perfectly reasonable customer acquisition cost.
The problem starts when you pay that same acquisition cost again the next year.
The OTA brought you the guest. Great.
Did you capture their email address? Cell number?
Did you build a relationship with them on social media?
Do you have book-direct and remarketing campaigns designed to bring them back?
Are there benefits to booking with you that are more compelling than what they receive through the OTA?
If the answer to most of those questions is no, then the OTA did not steal your repeat guest.
You handed the guest back.
Hotels love talking about customer ownership, but ownership is not automatic. You do not own a guest because they slept in one of your rooms once.
The first booking belongs to the OTA. The next one is yours to earn.
Hotels spend years building their brands, only to watch OTAs bid against them when travelers search those exact brand names on Google.
From the hotelier’s perspective, that feels a lot like hijacking.
From the OTA’s perspective, they helped introduce the traveler to the property in the first place and are simply trying to capture the booking created by that exposure, the classic billboard effect.
Both arguments have some truth to them.
Either way, hotels still have to capture the demand they worked so hard to generate.
Protect your branded search terms. Compete in metasearch. Make sure your direct channel is visible when someone is actively trying to find you.
And if you think this fight ends with Google and metasearch, buckle up. AI search is the next battleground for travel discovery, and you can be certain the OTAs are already preparing for it.
This might be my favorite excuse.
“My hotel only has a $100,000 marketing budget.”
“How much did you pay in OTA commissions last year?”
“About $400,000.”
Well, I have some good news for you.
You actually have a $500,000 marketing budget.
You just choose to give 80% of it to someone else to market your hotel for you.
Because OTA commission is a customer-acquisition expense.
If you are spending hundreds of thousands of dollars acquiring guests through OTAs but only a fraction of that trying to convert those guests into direct customers, the issue is not your budget.
It is your strategy.
OTAs are not the enemy.
They are arguably the best in the industry at new customer acquisition. They find travelers, build trust, reduce friction, and turn demand into bookings at a scale few hotels could ever replicate on their own.
That is exactly what we should use them for.
Let them find the guest. Let them make the introduction. Let them deliver the first booking.
Then take it from there.
Capture the customer information. Deliver a world-class guest experience. Nurture the relationship, remarket to them, and give them a reason to book direct.
If the OTA introduces you to the guest once, that is distribution.
But if they have to introduce you to the same guest twice, that is not an OTA problem.
That is a hotel problem.
Want to learn how Brittain Resorts & Hotels creates experiences that turn guests into lifelong advocates? Connect with us to explore our guest-centric management approach.
Please complete the form below and we’ll handle your request promptly. Thank you!
"*" indicates required fields
Please complete the requisition form on this page and we’ll handle your request promptly. Thank you!
"*" indicates required fields